A few days ago, I alluded to a possible review of the film Snow White and the Huntsman, which I saw with my girlfriend. I feel that I have to apologise to her for putting her through this rant again, because for about an hour after we saw it, all I could do was complain about how terrible Kristen Stewart was.
Yes, I have ranted about Twilight before, but now I would like to focus my rage on the so-called-star of the series, because I believe that she is possibly one of the worst actresses of all time. Ever. She’s the female Hayden Christianson, but don’t get me started on him now.
As far as the film goes, Snow White wasn’t actually that bad. I liked the action and I think that Chris Hemsworth is a good leading man. The special effects were very good, and Theron’s overacting was delightful to watch. I thought that the dwarves were actually a bit superfluous, they just seemed to be there, and anything that they did probably could have been done by anyone at all… That said, they are integral to the Snow White story, so I suppose they had to be there. Most of the film, I actually enjoyed.
The parts that I didn’t? Had everything to do with Kristen Stewart. She was just… terrible casting, just terrible, and I’m going to make you sit through the arguments that I’ve already made my girlfriend listen to (I’m sorry again).
1) The Fairest of them All
The reason that the wicked Queen wants Snow White dead is because she used to be the fairest of them all, but Snow White came of age and became the fairest of them all, knocking the Queen from the proverbial throne. There’s something about a magic spell thrown into this too, but that doesn’t matter. What does matter is this: Snow White is supposed to be more attractive than the Queen, otherwise the story falls apart completely.
So why did they cast someone so very unattractive like Stewart? Especially when compared to Theron! At no point during the film did I possibly believe that Stewart was considered more attractive/beautiful/fair.
But, I hear you say, exclaiming at the screen as if technology worked like that, what about her inner beauty? Surely that is what the mirror is referring to, for Snow White is purity itself and therefore more beautiful than the skin-deep Queen.
But the mirror has been saying that the Queen is the fairest of them all for years and years, which means that it doesn’t give a flying fig about inner beauty or anything like that. The mirror likes what it sees and doesn’t care about anything else. It’s the stupid sexist frat-boy approach to judging beauty. I’m surprised it didn’t need to be decided by a wet T-Shirt contest.
2) Purity and Life
A running idea through this movie was that Snow White was so pure and amazing, that she represented innocence and life itself. In fact, it’s this purity that is able to undo the Queen’s magic. I think that’s quite a cool idea, making her more than a pretty face.
But… again, why did they cast someone who was so awkward and out of place? Stewart has one setting when it comes to acting – dumb-struck nervousness. I’m sorry, I tell a lie. She has that setting and dumb-struck nervousness that’s trying to get its breath back. At no point did I believe that she was the incarnation of everything that is good. She could have tried, I don’t know, emoting? Smiling without looking like it’s causing her pain? Something to make us believe the other characters when they say she’s making them all feel so much better and brighter.
To me, it just looks like she’s making everyone else uncomfortable with her heavy breathing. Does she run laps around the studio before every take?
3) Battle Ready
At the end of the film, Snow White dons armour and a sword and leads an assault on the Queen’s castle (I won’t say too much more, for those who don’t want to know how the film ends). The film makers get points for trying to make the character active, but in the hands of Stewart, it just feels… helpless. I get that the character is supposed to be fragile, but there is a difference between fragility and being helpless. Stewart doesn’t seem to know that.
I’ve tried watching Stewart in other films. She was absolutely appalling in Twilight and I couldn’t get through Adventure Land, mostly thanks to her performance, but this one makes three films in which she’s been irredeemable. You know what sucks, though? I completely understand why the producers cast Stewart in the role. Being the highest paid actress of last year, Stewart can draw a crowd, which means that any film with her name attached will probably do quite well.
…
I hate that.
My girlfriend and I got into a discussion about who we would have cast instead. I suggested someone like Emma Stone or Anna Kendrick – both are fine actresses who I’m sure I could believe in a role like Snow White. They both have a happiness about them that Stewart doesn’t seem to be able to pull off.
My girlfriend countered with Anne Hathaway.
Needless to say, my girlfriend won that discussion. Hathaway would be perfect. She is very attractive, she can do action and she could make me believe that her Snow White makes the world brighter (she’s already done something similar in Hoodwinked).
I just can’t believe I didn’t think of that casting choice first…